Whoopie Pie Troubleshooting [5 Problems With Solutions]

Whoopie Pie Troubleshooting [5 Problems With Solutions]

Hey there, fellow culinary enthusiast! As you embark on this delectable journey through our articles, be prepared for a tantalizing adventure. Each click on our links could unveil delightful discoveries, possibly igniting your culinary creativity and, who knows, possibly adding a dash of sunshine to my day with a little commission from affiliate links. In other words, we sometimes earn a commission from partners listed. It's a win-win culinary rendezvous!

It’s a bummer when you want a whoopie pie but can’t make one correctly. Although it seems to be a simple procedure overall, a number of things may go wrong. But don’t be concerned; there are ways to avoid them, as I can assure you.

Whoopie pie troubleshooting

Your first problem might be Whoopie Pie didn’t rise. Another possible reason might be pie cranks. Your batter might get too thin. The flat whoopie pie looks like to be in an odd shape. Spreading pie with inadequate knowledge about whoopie pie might get you into trouble.

That was only a sample of what may go wrong with your whoopie pie. All of these problems have answers waiting for you to find them.

What’s the point of delaying it any longer? Let’s get this party started!

Whoopie Pie – 5 Major Problems & Solutions

Whoopie pie incorporates materials that are easily available and use simple processes. Some users, however, may have difficulties.

Problem 1: Whoopie Pies Doesn’t Rise

For a variety of causes, whoopie pies did not rise. The most common mistake is overmixing the cake batter. 

Be cautious not to curdle the dry components as you fold them into the wet ingredients. Only combine until the chocolate and flour are barely discernible.


Combine the oil, egg, vanilla extract, and sugar in a large mixing basin. To merge the ingredients, use an electric mixer at moderate speed. Mix them until they are well incorporated. 

In a medium-sized mixing bowl, combine 1 and 1/2 cups flour cocoa. Then, add baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Add the dry components to the rest of the ingredients one at a time, stirring constantly. 

Alternate between them and the milk, beating until smooth. Allow for a 15-minute resting period for the batter.

Problem 2: Whoopie Pie Cracks

Perhaps you are in a hurry, but you cannot bake your whoopie pie quickly. Cakes and other baked goods like cinnamon rolls may break at the top. This will happen if they are cooked for a short period of time.


Put the microwave to 350 ℉. In the microwave, place racks in the top and bottom thirds. Using cooking spray, coat two large baking sheets. 

Using a tablespoon, pour batter into baking sheets that have been prepared. Sometimes, the battery doesn’t spread evenly. Spread it out into a 2- to 3-inch circle. Bake the whoopie pie for 8 minutes. 

Allow for 2 minutes of cooling on the baking sheet before transferring. Please put it on a cooling rack. 

The baking sheets should be washed, dried, and sprayed once more with cooking spray. Using the leftover batter, repeat the procedure.

Problem 3: Whoopie Pie Comes Out Flat

Your whoopie pies may come out flat. It is most likely that the batter is too light in the first place. 

The proportions of the batter are essential to the outcome. If they are even slightly off, the batter will have problems.


Maintaining the right portions and methods is the key point to avoid whoopie pie flattening. 

Here is the ingredients list for the perfect measurements:

  • 1/2 cup vegetable shortening
  •  1 cup white sugar
  •  two eggs
  •  2 cups flour (all-purpose)
  •  5 tbsp cocoa powder (unsweetened)
  •  a quarter teaspoon of salt
  •  One teaspoon of baking soda
  •  1 cup of milk
  •  A third of a cup of shortening
  •  2 cups of sugar
  •  One teaspoon of salt
  •  One teaspoon of vanilla extract

Now, let’s get right into the procedure.


Cookie sheets should be greased before baking. To bake cookies, follow these instructions: 

First, 1/2 cup shortening, 1 cup sugar, and 2 egg yolks creamed together. Use a large mixing dish. Leave out the raw egg white if you don’t want to utilize it in your filling. 

To avoid having extra whites, use 1 whole egg instead of the 2 egg yolks. Mix all the dry elements in a separate dish. 

Gradually add the milk to the other mixture, beating thoroughly after each addition. Finish with a splash of vanilla extract. Put your batter for 10–15 minutes in the oven. Cool thoroughly on a wire rack.

Problem 4: Whoopie Pie Keeps Spreading

If your whoopie pie keeps spreading, there’s a slight chance you’re doing it wrong. Without proper refrigeration, your dough might be spreading unnaturally.


Preheat the oven to 350°F. Divide the batter between two baking sheets. This is to allow the cakes to spread. 

Instead of sugar and fat, use marshmallow crème enhanced with butter. This is to make a soft but solid core.

Problem 5: Inadequate Knowledge about Pie Defrosting

Sometimes, we make huge amounts of desserts to store for a sweet craving. Well, this might sound fancy, but you need to know about proper defrosting. Otherwise, your whoopie pie will taste flaky.

Remember that whoopie pies get muddier when left out for lengthy periods. When you eat the pie, the velvety filling becomes softer and gooier. It raises the probability of it spilling out.


These cookies are delicious in every way. They’re easy to bake and store. But the most excellent part about them is that they won’t need to be defrosted! Depending on how you choose to eat them, you have two options:

The first one is, Some prefer to eat their desserts chilled to avoid crumbs. The second one is to remove the cookies from the package. Set them on the counter for up to an hour.

So, how do you defrost a whoopie pie from the freezer? Take the whoopie pies out of the refrigerator and unroll them on a baking sheet. Then, please place them in the fridge overnight to cool.

Recommended reading – Pudding gets watery in fridge | What To Do With Failed Croissant Dough

What Is the Shelf Life of Whoopie Pies?

Many individuals are worried about the cookies’ shelf life. It is concerning since they include a butter-based mixture and eggs. They wonder whether whoopie pies need to be chilled.

Such elements don’t add much to the infinite storage term. How you keep whoopie pies will determine how long the dessert lasts.

It’s ideal for eating them as soon as possible once they’ve been prepared. The treats include buttercream. So, they will deteriorate quickly if not kept refrigerated. 

Depending on how soon the pie will be consumed, either refrigerate or frost them.

The whoopie cookies will last for about ten days if kept refrigerated.

Exposing them to cold for six months is the best method to preserve them. But we suggest completing them within two months for optimal quality.

Keeping whoopie pies in the cupboard or on the desk is not permitted. It is due to the buttery filling spoiling quickly. But butter plays a vital role in crumbly shortbread dough

It also causes unpleasant consequences. If you aren’t going to consume them instantly, put them in the freezer.

Now another thing, what about the lasting duration of whoopie pies? If stored correctly in the freezer, whoopie pies may last up to three months. The taste of frozen whoopie pies does not deteriorate and is still edible. 

Cover each pie in plastic wrap before freezing it to extend its shelf life. Here, I’ve recommended eco-friendly plastic wraps for your convenience. Take a look!

  • SealWrap 30510600 Zipsafe Plastic Wrap
  • SuperBee Wax Wraps Reusable Beeswax Wraps

We hope these product suggestions will help you to complete your baking with ease.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are whoopie pies sticky?

Due to high humidity, your pie will get gummy if left out for too long. This is true for the majority of whoopie pies. Cover each one separately in plastic wrap to avoid the pies from sticking together.

Can you leave whoopie pies out?

Yes! A tightly sealed container of whoopie pies can keep them fresh. Keep them at room temperature for up to 5 days. Cover each whoopie pie separately with plastic wrap. Set them in a sealed container to keep them fresh longer.

Are gobs and whoopie pies the same?

Unpalatable marshmallow topping layered among graham crackers and dipped in a dark oily liquid. It also defies the notion of “cocoa.” A gob is two “biscuit” discs formed from a choco cake mixed with flour.

Final Thoughts

Whoopie pies are a delightful dessert that appeals to both the young and the elderly. I hope I have cleared all your doubts about whoopie pie troubleshooting. 

Whoopie pies may be stored at room temperature for a day or two to keep them fresh. Please place it in sealed containers for long-term freshness. To preserve the taste of the center and shell, you need to do the same thing.

Best of luck baking your favorite whoopie pie!

About The Author

Scroll to Top