Whip Cream vs Buttercream [ULTIMATE Battle]

Whip Cream vs Buttercream [ULTIMATE Battle]

Hey there, fellow culinary enthusiast! As you embark on this delectable journey through our articles, be prepared for a tantalizing adventure. Each click on our links could unveil delightful discoveries, possibly igniting your culinary creativity and, who knows, possibly adding a dash of sunshine to my day with a little commission from affiliate links. In other words, we sometimes earn a commission from partners listed. It's a win-win culinary rendezvous!

Let’s talk desserts! You won’t find a lot of people that don’t have a sweet tooth. Desserts are like a warm, sweet hug that smells and looks great!

An essential reason why desserts taste satisfyingly sweet and look appealing is because of their frosting. If you’re a baking enthusiast, you know how important it is to get the frosting right!

The two popular frosting choices are whip cream and Buttercream. So, which one to choose?

Whip cream vs buttercream: Which one’s better?

There is more than one factor to consider when picking the winner between whip cream and Buttercream including the recipes, flavor, texture, and storage. The better cream depends on your requirements and the recipe you’ve chosen.

For example, whip cream is a fluffier and more delicate cream, while Buttercream has a thicker consistency. So, the one you choose depends on what suits your recipe best.

Whip cream and Buttercream are both excellent options. However, when deciding what type of frosting suits your dessert, there is more than one factor to consider. It can be a little exhausting to find out which one of these frostings suits your cake or muffins better.

So, consider me your frosting angel because I will help you choose. Continue reading today’s “whip cream v/s buttercream” post to learn more!

Before diving into the difference between whip cream and buttercream frosting, let’s take a closer look at each.

What is whip cream?

Whip cream is a creamy and light dessert topping made by whipping heavy cream until it reaches a thick and fluffy consistency. It is a popular addition to various desserts, fruits, and beverages, adding a delightful and creamy touch.

The taste and texture of whipped cream are rich, creamy, and mildly sweet. It enhances the flavors of desserts and provides a velvety mouthfeel.

Whipped cream can be served as a topping on pies, cakes, ice cream, hot beverages like hot chocolate or coffee, and other desserts. It can also be used as an ingredient in mousses, frostings, and creamy fillings for pastries.

Whip cream can be made with different variations, such as adding sweeteners like sugar or flavorings like vanilla extract for additional taste. Non-dairy alternatives are available, made with ingredients like coconut milk or soy milk, for those with dietary restrictions or preferences.

It’s important to note that whipped cream is perishable and best-consumed fresh. It can be stored in the refrigerator briefly before losing its texture and consistency.

What is Buttercream?

Buttercream is a classic and versatile frosting widely used in cake decorating and baking. The creamy texture and sweet flavor make it a delicious addition to various desserts. Buttercream is commonly used to decorate cakes, cupcakes, and pastries. The taste of Buttercream is rich, sweet, buttery, with a smooth and velvety texture. It adds a luxurious element to baked goods and is a popular choice for frosting due to its versatility and ability to hold its shape. 

Buttercream is made primarily from butter, powdered sugar, and other flavorings and ingredients, resulting in a smooth and creamy texture. The critical ingredient of Buttercream is butter, which is typically softened or at room temperature before use. The butter is beaten with powdered sugar to create a fluffy and spreadable consistency. The proportions of butter to sugar can vary depending on the desired sweetness and texture of the Buttercream.

In addition to butter and sugar, various flavorings can be added to Buttercream, such as vanilla extract, almond extract, or other flavor extracts. These flavorings help enhance the taste and aroma of the Buttercream. Additionally, a small amount of milk or cream can be added to adjust the consistency and make the Buttercream easier to work with.

Buttercream can be customized with food coloring to create vibrant colors for cake decoration or piped designs. It is often used as a base for intricate cake decorations, such as flowers, rosettes, or piping details. It can also be spread smoothly over the surface of cakes or used to keep the layers stuck to one another.

Recommended readingWhat is bitter cream | Lo Mein vs Mei Fun | Ancho vs Achiote

How to chose between Whip Cream vs Buttercream

We must understand their differences since we’ve seen what separates whip cream and Buttercream!

The frosting is an integral part of a dessert as it contributes to the taste and visual appeal. Both whip cream and Buttercream are incredible frosting options. However, when it comes down to it, which one should you choose? Well, there isn’t a direct answer to this question. It is essential to take a closer look at each factor and understand which of these frostings best suits your dessert. 

Recipe

First, let’s talk about the ingredients of whip cream and Buttercream. Typically, American Buttercream is made by mixing powdered sugar with butter, milk, and flavorings like vanilla extract. These ingredients are thoroughly whisked together to produce a smooth paste with a medium to thick consistency. 

Whip cream has a more straightforward recipe: whipping heavy cream until it becomes soft and creamy. After whisking it, add more sugar, vanilla, or other extracts to jazz up the taste! Whip cream can sometimes be unstable, especially a higher temperatures. Using some meringue powder is an excellent idea to provide stability.

Flavor Profile and Texture

Now, to the most critical factor: Taste and Texture! Regardless of how these frostings have fared in other aspects, the taste must be on point. 

Buttercream is a satisfyingly sweet frosting that has a buttery element. Vanilla extracts, cocoa powder, or other flavorings are usually added to enhance the sweet taste. On the other hand, whip cream has a light, creamy, rich taste, and a milder sweet taste. It is generally flavored with cinnamon, vanilla, and even peppermint.

Next is texture. Buttercream has a rich, creamy texture and is spreadable on cakes. It has a thick to medium consistency and is sturdier than whip cream. Buttercream also forms a crust layer over its soft, creamy texture, making it perfect for layered cakes. Whip cream is much lighter and airy in consistency. It has a delicate texture with some frothing formed by tiny air pockets. So, it is not suitable as a spread on desserts. However, it is an excellent option to pipe borders on margins on cakes and other baked goods.

Application

Buttercream is a popularly used frosting on cookies, cakes, and muffins. You can easily create beautiful and intricate designs on your cake as it has a medium to thick consistency. Recreating the exact details with whip cream can be challenging as it is fluffier and delicate. However, whip cream is perfect for piping borders on cakes and cupcakes.

If you have complex desserts to frost, such as wedding cakes, Buttercream will do a better job of being adherent by creating a crusty layer. On the other hand, whip cream is much more delicate and soft. It is not capable of holding such cakes together.

Buttercream can also tolerate high temperatures, unlike whip cream, which loses its integrity at similar temperatures. So, if you are planning on using frosting for high-temperature desserts, Buttercream is the way to go. 

Storage

Finally, let’s discuss storage. Buttercream has a shelf life of about two weeks in the refrigerator. It needs to be appropriately stored in an airtight container to prevent it from becoming stale. If you want to store it outside, I recommend consuming it in about 2 to 3 days. Please ensure that you thoroughly cover it at room temperature.

Whip cream has a significantly shorter shelf life. It only stays for up to 2 days in the refrigerator. And storing it outside isn’t an option. Since it is mainly whipped cream, it shouldn’t be stored outside due to instability. 

Which one to Select – Buttercream vs Whip cream

I hope the above comparison helped you choose the frosting type. It is undoubtedly a tough decision; whip cream and Buttercream are incredible frostings! If you need a final nudge in deciding which one to go with, here are some quick points about whip cream v/s buttercream:

  • Buttercream has a rich, creamy taste. On the other hand, whip cream has an airy, creamy taste but is less sweet. So, you can choose one based on how much sweetness you prefer. 
  • Buttercream works like a charm if you want to make pretty designs with intricate details on your cake. However, whip cream is not as sturdy as Buttercream and, therefore, cannot be used to create such designs. Nevertheless, you can do incredible piping work on cakes and cupcakes with whip cream. You can use whip cream with sponge cakes and angel food cakes.
  • For those wanting to add some delicious flavoring to take their frosting a notch higher, here’s what you need to know: The texture of Buttercream doesn’t significantly change upon adding flavors like coffee, chocolate, maple, etc. But whip cream is not the best at accommodating these ingredients and is likely to change texture sometimes.
  • Lastly, the shelf life. The shelf life of Buttercream is much longer than whip cream. Whip cream lasts only 2 to 3 days in the fridge, whereas Buttercream can last up to two weeks. So, if you anticipate a lot of leftovers, it is best to go with Buttercream as you can enjoy it for an extended period.

Suitable frosting depends on your taste preference and the recipe you’re recreating.

Buttercream is ideal for tiered cakes as it keeps the layer together by forming a crust. It is also the type of frosting used to create beautiful designs and details.

It is also more tolerant to higher temperatures, so if your recipe demands heat-tolerant frosting, Buttercream is the answer.

Whip cream is a delicious, light, airy frosting that is exceptionally versatile. It is not just used on cakes and cupcakes but also in beverages and other culinary preparations. It is an excellent choice to use on sponge cakes and angel cakes. You can create incredible, delicious-looking borders for the cakes. 

Interesting further reading – Hash Browns Vs Tater Tots | Do Potatoes Float? | How Much Frozen Spinach Equals One Cup Fresh?

Frequently Asked Questions

Does whipped cream last on a cake?

It is recommended to eat whip cream as soon as it has been piped on the cake. Whipped cream is unstable and loses its integrity at room temperature. If you want to save the leftovers, store them in your refrigerator for 2 to 3 days. Please ensure that the whipped cream has not deflated or started to separate before eating it.

What kind of cake does buttercream frosting taste the best on?

Buttercream is a versatile frosting that goes with most flavors. You can add your twist of flavors to your Buttercream. Some popular choices are chocolate, cinnamon, vanilla, coffee, and many more! You can choose and adjust the flavor of your Buttercream based on your cake’s flavor.

What is the best type of frosting for decorating?

If you want to create pretty designs and details on your cake, the consistency of Buttercream allows you to do so. It has a medium to thick consistency and is sturdy on being piped over cakes. It is also great for multi-tiered cakes as it helps by sticking the layers to each other by forming a thin crust. It helps maintain the original form of your dessert.

Conclusion

Now, to the end of the post! I hope today’s post on whip cream vs buttercream has given you an answer for what frosting to use. There is no doubt that both whip cream and Buttercream are incredible frosting options. However, the better cream depends on your taste preference and your dessert.

If you’re looking to create intricate designs, layered cakes, or high-temp desserts, Buttercream is the answer. But if you want a less sweet, light frosting alternative, whip cream works great.

Amazon typically has great prices on both whip cream and Buttercream.

You can add flavorings that you enjoy to your frosting to take your dessert to new levels! 

Thanks for reading our post. See you in our next post! 

About The Author

Scroll to Top